PR Rejected

[pccounter]

Hello Friends,

My PR application got rejected in 3 months time, here are some facts

>Principal Applicant EP P1 (Indian National)
>Dependent Applicant wife (Pakistani National) & 7 year old Son (Indian National) on DP
>Duration of Stay in Singapore - 3 years
>Paying 5 figure Income Tax & Corporate Tax separately
>Principal Applicant Gross Salary SGD 200k per year Excluding Bonus & Commission
>working as Managing Director in company and employed 5 Singaporean, 1 PR & 2 foreigner
>Principal Applicant solely responsible for compound growth of company in past three year with financial turnover of SGD 75 Million in year 2012

Friends, kindly advise as what is going wrong in my application.

[rdueej]

Hello Friends,

My PR application got rejected in 3 months time, here are some facts

>Principal Applicant EP P1 (Indian National)
>Dependent Applicant wife (Pakistani National) & 7 year old Son (Indian National) on DP
>Duration of Stay in Singapore - 3 years
>Paying 5 figure Income Tax & Corporate Tax separately
>Principal Applicant Gross Salary SGD 200k per year Excluding Bonus & Commission
>working as Managing Director in company and employed 5 Singaporean, 1 PR & 2 foreigner
>Principal Applicant solely responsible for compound growth of company in past three year with financial turnover of SGD 75 Million in year 2012

Friends, kindly advise as what is going wrong in my application.

Apart from nationality, everything else looks great in your application, unless you are not revealing any other relevant information. I cannot think of much cause for rejection.

Wait for the letter in the mail, it might invite you to apply again after a few more months/years.

[pccounter]

letter has already came in with no explanation, starting with "after careful consideration your application has been rejected and you can continue living in Singapore on your valid passes"

I have listed all relevant information i could think of

[nakatago]

letter has already came in with no explanation, starting with "after careful consideration your application has been rejected and you can continue living in Singapore on your valid passes"

I have listed all relevant information i could think of

That means they don't want you to apply for PR again unless the government changes its mind about its unspoken policies. Otherwise, the letter would've stated you can apply again after X years.

[pccounter]

letter has already came in with no explanation, starting with "after careful consideration your application has been rejected and you can continue living in Singapore on your valid passes"

I have listed all relevant information i could think of

That means they don't want you to apply for PR again unless the government changes its mind about its unspoken policies. Otherwise, the letter would've stated you can apply again after X years.

Yeah looks like pretty much the case here where all logic fails

[FaeLLe]

Time to purchase a different nationality from Saint Kitts or through investment program in the UK...

[PNGMK]

Hello Friends,

My PR application got rejected in 3 months time, here are some facts

>Principal Applicant EP P1 (Indian National)
>Dependent Applicant wife (Pakistani National) & 7 year old Son (Indian National) on DP
>Duration of Stay in Singapore - 3 years
>Paying 5 figure Income Tax & Corporate Tax separately
>Principal Applicant Gross Salary SGD 200k per year Excluding Bonus & Commission
>working as Managing Director in company and employed 5 Singaporean, 1 PR & 2 foreigner
>Principal Applicant solely responsible for compound growth of company in past three year with financial turnover of SGD 75 Million in year 2012

Friends, kindly advise as what is going wrong in my application.

Nothing is wrong with your application. Save your money, enjoy the work and plan for your next move. Don't take these things personally.

[PNGMK]

Time to purchase a different nationality from Saint Kitts or through investment program in the UK...

Or perhaps lobby for an internal transfer to the US or UK.

[katbh]

Just a thought.... are you over 50?

[pccounter]

I am 40

[IronMac]

Very fast rejection!

I don't see any mention of education?

[FaeLLe]

Very fast rejection!

I don't see any mention of education?

Usually education is not a criteria for people beyond a threshold e.g. P1 Pass holders , Gahmen would assume they continue in other ways.

[katbh]

FaeLle
Not sure if you have an in or not at ICA but from my experience education is VERY important to any immigration application in Singapore. Prior to 2 years ago it was not so important - now it is seen as very important.

[PNGMK]

FaeLle
Not sure if you have an in or not at ICA but from my experience education is VERY important to any immigration application in Singapore. Prior to 2 years ago it was not so important - now it is seen as very important.

+1 - the OP would be need to pull in significantly more (think like Mustaffaa level) before his education would not matter - this is a society that is engineered and eugenics plays a part.

I personally suspect (and this is terrible to say) that his wife's nationality and possibly religion (and hence his) may have played a part. I'm sure ICA keeps not only nationalities and races in balance but also religions.

[fliperz]

I heard that even your education plays a part when applying PR. They even ask about your family background etc.