Stock tip club?

Post by **PNGMK** » Mon, 08 Jul 2013 10:47 pm

Obviously we cannot inside trade but is anyone here interested in starting a stock tip club?

Wd40 · Post by **Wd40** » Tue, 09 Jul 2013 4:24 am

I am interested in joining. I think it should rather be investment club. Stocks, Equity funds and Bond funds.

zzm9980 · Post by **zzm9980** » Tue, 09 Jul 2013 11:12 am

How does a club compare vs just a discussion thread?

Post by **PNGMK** » Tue, 09 Jul 2013 11:17 am

zzm9980 wrote:How does a club compare vs just a discussion thread?

To be honest I figured it should be online but a closed thread. Essentially a tip swapping thread.... but no lurkers... if you don't contribute you're out.

Post by **Strong Eagle** » Tue, 09 Jul 2013 11:28 am

PNGMK wrote:
zzm9980 wrote:How does a club compare vs just a discussion thread?
To be honest I figured it should be online but a closed thread. Essentially a tip swapping thread.... but no lurkers... if you don't contribute you're out.

This board doesn't have closed threads.

Post by **PNGMK** » Tue, 09 Jul 2013 12:40 pm

Strong Eagle wrote:
PNGMK wrote:
zzm9980 wrote:How does a club compare vs just a discussion thread?
To be honest I figured it should be online but a closed thread. Essentially a tip swapping thread.... but no lurkers... if you don't contribute you're out.
This board doesn't have closed threads.

Yes I realize that.

durain · Post by **durain** » Tue, 09 Jul 2013 5:53 pm

how about encryption?

Post by **nakatago** » Tue, 09 Jul 2013 6:23 pm

Google+ community?

Post by **x9200** » Wed, 10 Jul 2013 9:56 am

durain wrote:how about encryption?

This you can always do but I think it makes very little sense over a public forum. Even plain e-mail is more practical.

Code: Select all

-----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.13 (Darwin)
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=nxQD
-----END PGP MESSAGE-----

zzm9980 · Post by **zzm9980** » Wed, 10 Jul 2013 1:06 pm

x9200 wrote:

durain wrote:how about encryption?

This you can always do but I think it makes very little sense over a public forum. Even plain e-mail is more practical.

Code: Select all

-----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.13 (Darwin)
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=nxQD
-----END PGP MESSAGE-----

EBG13 jbhyq guebj bss zbfg bs gur ernqref urer.

Free drink to the first person to "decode" that at next meet.

BillyB · Post by **BillyB** » Wed, 10 Jul 2013 1:11 pm

'One of the funny things about the stock market is that every time one person buys, another sells, and both think they are astute'.

nutnut · Post by **nutnut** » Wed, 10 Jul 2013 1:35 pm

ROT13 doesn't throw me off zzm, it's a very simple but effective code though, I've used it many times before.

EBG13 jbhyq guebj bss zbfg bs gur ernqref urer

=

"ROT13 would throw off most of the readers here"

Mine's a pint.

Grumpy77 · Post by **Grumpy77** » Wed, 10 Jul 2013 9:05 pm

The negative first: if you are trying to get a bunch of random punters chucking 'tips' out online, then you'll find there are few 'tipsters' as it's a very asymetric landscape. If you have something good, why tell the world... Thus online and anonymous tips tend to be worse than worthless since they must be taken as pump and dump - almost for-sure losers.

I'm interested but every time someone says 'anyone interested to do .... (insert activity)', it seems to fizzle out. There is never an impetus to do it.

I'd suggest you say: Anyone interested in joining a stock/investment club, please come to .... (insert venue, time, etc) - with an RSVP. Make it actionable, not vague and you will have at least a small chance of it happening.

If you want to be chairperson of a 'club', I'll come for a mtg or two at the very least to see what kind of fun can be had. With luck, we can get BillyB to come and tell us some trading tales. If we have to bribe him with beer, so be it

I used to be involved with some online full-time traders called SGX-Traders and we had monthly meetings that were quite interesting. Getting traders of different flavours together can add value.

I'd be curious to see if there are enough folk interested have a pint and discuss some ideas to make this worthwhile. You are right that it needs to be a 'sharing' group. Everyone expected to put ideas forward with justification for discussion. As soon as there are more than a few clubsters, it should have some structure if you want it to be worthwhile.

But if all we get is 2 of us, let's have a beer and talk trades, I'm happy to listen and promise to share far more.

PM if you want to talk... Cheers,

Post by **Strong Eagle** » Wed, 10 Jul 2013 10:51 pm

BillyB wrote:'One of the funny things about the stock market is that every time one person buys, another sells, and both think they are astute'.

+100,000

zzm9980 · Post by **zzm9980** » Wed, 10 Jul 2013 11:01 pm

nutnut wrote:ROT13 doesn't throw me off zzm, it's a very simple but effective code though, I've used it many times before.

EBG13 jbhyq guebj bss zbfg bs gur ernqref urer

=

"ROT13 would throw off most of the readers here"

Mine's a pint.

Nutnut, I'd buy you a pint anyway. Cheers!

SINGAPORE EXPATS FORUM
Singapore Expat Forum and Message Board for Expats in Singapore & Expatriates Relocating to Singapore

Stock tip club?

Stock tip club?

Who is online