I don't see it, the crippling corruption is a major reason why the Philippines is behind most Asian countries nowadays, 50 years ago I'm reliably informed it was way ahead of Singapore, Malaysia etc... unless something major changes in that respect, it will remain one of the poorer nations. One paper though I agree, a large English-speaking, reasonably well-educated population should be doing well, it's just that the politicians there make the EU leadership look like the most competent and honest people on the planet!movingtospore wrote:And the Philippines...they are coming on strong, decent education, entrepreneurial, they work in English, and are hungry to grow. I think they are going to surpass this tiny place in no time.sundaymorningstaple wrote:v4jr4, no, I wouldn't assume that at all. As you have already read, quota's have been chopped for both S passes AND WORK PERMITS. The Services sector has been chopped over all by 5 percent and the sub-quota for S pass holders has also been cut by 5%. The WP's are your low level workers. They are being reduced.
What is happening is that they are upping the levies to astronomical levels and cutting back the overall quotas. This will eventually lead to a point where it doesn't make any economic sense to bring in foreigner. Then, in order to get the picky locals to take up these jobs, the companies will be forced to pay a decent wage in order to get the local to accept it, even though it goes against the grain. The employers are the ones who get screwed as their costs go up, but their productivity doesn't, due to the shoddy work habits of locals and their constant just walking off the job. They employers will have no choice but to keep hiring locals as the gahmen continue to reduce the quotas.
This will keep up until a number of MNC shift their operations to Malaysia and/or Thailand because of labour costs. Then unemployment WILL make itself felt (it's been 0% for years - well 2% structural which is nothing). When that happens, the locals, the gahmen, Singapore......All screwed. The PAP will be voted out if they don't get rid of a lot of foreigners and when the MNCs start leaving because they cannot get manpower, they PAP will get voted out. Damned if they do and damned if they don't. The local population doesn't realize that as long as they have a decreasing fertility rate, it's going to get worse. It's coming, mark my words.
SINGAPORE EXPATS FORUM
Singapore Expat Forum and Message Board for Expats in Singapore & Expatriates Relocating to Singapore
Doesn't Harry like Indonesians?
I HAVE MASTERS!
Re: Doesn't Harry like Indonesians?
No need to turn like this. I will be happy to explain some more difficult parts, you just need to be a bit more specific.IOP wrote:whatever floats your boat.x9200 wrote: Firstly, if your presence on this board was less incidental you would notice that there are hardly anybody from the regulars that questions the practicality of the SG government. So in general you brought in a heavy artillery to kill a non-existing target. Instead, what has been repeated here many times is that Singapore is an enterprise, well managed enterprise.
Secondly, your oldies saying is the same class as the modified one. It's a smart ass response that conveniently omits all the background factors leading to a success or a failure. I don't think anyone mature enough should be afraid and have problems answering it.
Lastly, OSD just mentioned there are people worth to be considered outside the current approach and you built up a theory around this sentence that IMHO has nothing to do with his intentions.
- Strong Eagle
- Moderator
- Posts: 11504
- Joined: Sat, 10 Jul 2004 12:13 am
- Location: Off The Red Dot
- Contact:
It's corruption... and another issue... Filipinos are just too nice. I mean, introducing real accountability into a management structure.JayCee wrote:I don't see it, the crippling corruption is a major reason why the Philippines is behind most Asian countries nowadays, 50 years ago I'm reliably informed it was way ahead of Singapore, Malaysia etc... unless something major changes in that respect, it will remain one of the poorer nations. One paper though I agree, a large English-speaking, reasonably well-educated population should be doing well, it's just that the politicians there make the EU leadership look like the most competent and honest people on the planet!movingtospore wrote:And the Philippines...they are coming on strong, decent education, entrepreneurial, they work in English, and are hungry to grow. I think they are going to surpass this tiny place in no time.sundaymorningstaple wrote:v4jr4, no, I wouldn't assume that at all. As you have already read, quota's have been chopped for both S passes AND WORK PERMITS. The Services sector has been chopped over all by 5 percent and the sub-quota for S pass holders has also been cut by 5%. The WP's are your low level workers. They are being reduced.
What is happening is that they are upping the levies to astronomical levels and cutting back the overall quotas. This will eventually lead to a point where it doesn't make any economic sense to bring in foreigner. Then, in order to get the picky locals to take up these jobs, the companies will be forced to pay a decent wage in order to get the local to accept it, even though it goes against the grain. The employers are the ones who get screwed as their costs go up, but their productivity doesn't, due to the shoddy work habits of locals and their constant just walking off the job. They employers will have no choice but to keep hiring locals as the gahmen continue to reduce the quotas.
This will keep up until a number of MNC shift their operations to Malaysia and/or Thailand because of labour costs. Then unemployment WILL make itself felt (it's been 0% for years - well 2% structural which is nothing). When that happens, the locals, the gahmen, Singapore......All screwed. The PAP will be voted out if they don't get rid of a lot of foreigners and when the MNCs start leaving because they cannot get manpower, they PAP will get voted out. Damned if they do and damned if they don't. The local population doesn't realize that as long as they have a decreasing fertility rate, it's going to get worse. It's coming, mark my words.
One of many examples that I've come across over the years. It's a Manila based service desk. Client is a large MNC within offices from ANZ to India.
Australians are complaining bitterly that no one answers the phone. Finally, I fly to Manila. I get up so that I can be at the call center at 4:30 in the morning (Australia start of business, 3 hours ahead).
There are supposed to be two ANZ agents... there are none. There is one overnight agent, a dear. I ask her, "the ANZ agents are not here. Have you reported this?" No, she says... I didn't want to get anyone in trouble.
I meet with the service desk manager. I ask him if he has reviewed the telephony login logs. Yes, he says. Then, I says, you must know the ANZ agents have not been at work, else you would have seen their logins.
Yes, he says, they are not logging in... I didn't want to get anyone in trouble.
And folks, this is the essence of the issue for me. Great people, gentle people, and so hard to enforce accountability, so hard to get someone to kick another in the balls when it is so richly deserved.
I can't say much about other aspects of Philippine employment, but I can say that it seriously affects the ability to create a premium product when the deficient are not being weeded out by managers who don't want to offend or get someone in trouble.
Wow, sounds worse than my experiences with our Indian ODCs. We show up to an ODC with a headcount of ~500. As of 2pm, only ~325 had badged in that day. Where are the rest we ask? After an hour of scurring, management can only find leave records for about 30. ~130+ are on "unplanned leave", and just not showing up. See I just chalked it up to them trying to rip us off and over-charge, not people being too nice and covering for each other.Strong Eagle wrote:One of many examples that I've come across over the years. It's a Manila based service desk. Client is a large MNC within offices from ANZ to India.
Australians are complaining bitterly that no one answers the phone. Finally, I fly to Manila. I get up so that I can be at the call center at 4:30 in the morning (Australia start of business, 3 hours ahead).
There are supposed to be two ANZ agents... there are none. There is one overnight agent, a dear. I ask her, "the ANZ agents are not here. Have you reported this?" No, she says... I didn't want to get anyone in trouble.
I meet with the service desk manager. I ask him if he has reviewed the telephony login logs. Yes, he says. Then, I says, you must know the ANZ agents have not been at work, else you would have seen their logins.
Yes, he says, they are not logging in... I didn't want to get anyone in trouble.
And folks, this is the essence of the issue for me. Great people, gentle people, and so hard to enforce accountability, so hard to get someone to kick another in the balls when it is so richly deserved.
I can't say much about other aspects of Philippine employment, but I can say that it seriously affects the ability to create a premium product when the deficient are not being weeded out by managers who don't want to offend or get someone in trouble.
- the lynx
- Governor
- Posts: 5281
- Joined: Thu, 09 Dec 2010 6:29 pm
- Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location:
Sorry for my ignorance, but what is an ODC?zzm9980 wrote:Wow, sounds worse than my experiences with our Indian ODCs. We show up to an ODC with a headcount of ~500. As of 2pm, only ~325 had badged in that day. Where are the rest we ask? After an hour of scurring, management can only find leave records for about 30. ~130+ are on "unplanned leave", and just not showing up. See I just chalked it up to them trying to rip us off and over-charge, not people being too nice and covering for each other.
No, I'm sorry. I realize it wouldn't be a familiar term to anyone who isn't involved in outsourcing.the lynx wrote:Sorry for my ignorance, but what is an ODC?zzm9980 wrote:Wow, sounds worse than my experiences with our Indian ODCs. We show up to an ODC with a headcount of ~500. As of 2pm, only ~325 had badged in that day. Where are the rest we ask? After an hour of scurring, management can only find leave records for about 30. ~130+ are on "unplanned leave", and just not showing up. See I just chalked it up to them trying to rip us off and over-charge, not people being too nice and covering for each other.
ODC = Offshore/Outsourced Development Center
When you outsource a portion of your operations to a big Indian firm, they setup an ODC for you. Basically it is the physical location(s) inside their company where "your" employees all sit. A lot of these companies will have these giant campuses with multiple buildings, and each floor of each building will usually be subdivided into these ODCs, maybe two-six of them per floor. You'll just walk down a hall and see all of these cubicles behind glass windows locked in behind badge-controlled doors. Each of these is like a "mini-outpost" for the company they're outsourced too. Occasionally they'll have shared ones, where multiple companies mingle, but most banks and MNCs don't allow that.
- the lynx
- Governor
- Posts: 5281
- Joined: Thu, 09 Dec 2010 6:29 pm
- Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location: Location:
Ah, I've always known of such operations but never knew it was called ODCzzm9980 wrote:No, I'm sorry. I realize it wouldn't be a familiar term to anyone who isn't involved in outsourcing.the lynx wrote:Sorry for my ignorance, but what is an ODC?zzm9980 wrote:Wow, sounds worse than my experiences with our Indian ODCs. We show up to an ODC with a headcount of ~500. As of 2pm, only ~325 had badged in that day. Where are the rest we ask? After an hour of scurring, management can only find leave records for about 30. ~130+ are on "unplanned leave", and just not showing up. See I just chalked it up to them trying to rip us off and over-charge, not people being too nice and covering for each other.
ODC = Offshore/Outsourced Development Center
When you outsource a portion of your operations to a big Indian firm, they setup an ODC for you. Basically it is the physical location(s) inside their company where "your" employees all sit. A lot of these companies will have these giant campuses with multiple buildings, and each floor of each building will usually be subdivided into these ODCs, maybe two-six of them per floor. You'll just walk down a hall and see all of these cubicles behind glass windows locked in behind badge-controlled doors. Each of these is like a "mini-outpost" for the company they're outsourced too. Occasionally they'll have shared ones, where multiple companies mingle, but most banks and MNCs don't allow that.

That's a good point. Here in Singapore I notice that in the places I've worked in, the filipino workers tend to be very friendly with each other, usually all go out together for lunch, go out for breaks together around 5pm. There's not much interaction with other groups socially, generally they stick together (nothing wrong with that as birds of a feather etc...)Strong Eagle wrote:It's corruption... and another issue... Filipinos are just too nice. I mean, introducing real accountability into a management structure.JayCee wrote:I don't see it, the crippling corruption is a major reason why the Philippines is behind most Asian countries nowadays, 50 years ago I'm reliably informed it was way ahead of Singapore, Malaysia etc... unless something major changes in that respect, it will remain one of the poorer nations. One paper though I agree, a large English-speaking, reasonably well-educated population should be doing well, it's just that the politicians there make the EU leadership look like the most competent and honest people on the planet!movingtospore wrote: And the Philippines...they are coming on strong, decent education, entrepreneurial, they work in English, and are hungry to grow. I think they are going to surpass this tiny place in no time.
One of many examples that I've come across over the years. It's a Manila based service desk. Client is a large MNC within offices from ANZ to India.
Australians are complaining bitterly that no one answers the phone. Finally, I fly to Manila. I get up so that I can be at the call center at 4:30 in the morning (Australia start of business, 3 hours ahead).
There are supposed to be two ANZ agents... there are none. There is one overnight agent, a dear. I ask her, "the ANZ agents are not here. Have you reported this?" No, she says... I didn't want to get anyone in trouble.
I meet with the service desk manager. I ask him if he has reviewed the telephony login logs. Yes, he says. Then, I says, you must know the ANZ agents have not been at work, else you would have seen their logins.
Yes, he says, they are not logging in... I didn't want to get anyone in trouble.
And folks, this is the essence of the issue for me. Great people, gentle people, and so hard to enforce accountability, so hard to get someone to kick another in the balls when it is so richly deserved.
I can't say much about other aspects of Philippine employment, but I can say that it seriously affects the ability to create a premium product when the deficient are not being weeded out by managers who don't want to offend or get someone in trouble.
I don't see this level of 'comraderie' amongst the other groups, indeed for the largest group (Indian - take a wild guess what kind of job I do) I get the impression that they would kick eachother's grandparents onto the street if it would get them a payrise or promotion.
I HAVE MASTERS!
- sundaymorningstaple
- Moderator
- Posts: 39771
- Joined: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 1:26 pm
- Location: Retired on the Little Red Dot
In every other industry the Chinese are exactly the same way.JayCee wrote:
....indeed for the largest group (Indian - take a wild guess what kind of job I do) I get the impression that they would kick eachother's grandparents onto the street if it would get them a payrise or promotion.
SOME PEOPLE TRY TO TURN BACK THEIR ODOMETERS. NOT ME. I WANT PEOPLE TO KNOW WHY I LOOK THIS WAY. I'VE TRAVELED A LONG WAY, AND SOME OF THE ROADS WEREN'T PAVED. ~ Will Rogers
Yah, but sometimes, the cameraderie gets dirty .. like Strong Eagle mentionedJayCee wrote: That's a good point. Here in Singapore I notice that in the places I've worked in, the filipino workers tend to be very friendly with each other, usually all go out together for lunch, go out for breaks together around 5pm. There's not much interaction with other groups socially, generally they stick together (nothing wrong with that as birds of a feather etc...)
I don't see this level of 'comraderie' amongst the other groups, indeed for the largest group (Indian - take a wild guess what kind of job I do) I get the impression that they would kick eachother's grandparents onto the street if it would get them a payrise or promotion.
Some time ago, I tried to report a problem with a service, and the call center person, when she found out the complaint was about a 'fellow citizen' tried to not lodge the complaint and very clearly refusing to admit the mistake.
And when I insisted that she escalate her next level person had been breifed very well, she too refused to lodge the complaint ..
On and an on it went up to 4 levels up, and I gave up.
Wrote a complaint letter, the old fashioned way, and a 'non-citizen' of the person involved called back within 3 days, and was very apolegetic and insisted I provide more details .. and when I asked whether the whole gang will be advised to show more professionalism, the answer was startling .. 'well, we cannot do much, all the above people are outsourced and not in Singapore .. we know, but our management does the dollar and cents and the cheaper staff come out winners .. ' or he too admitted ..
And by that time, my temper had gone down to negative numbers, and was in no mood to fight it out or 'fix' the people .. if I could ..
No offense to anybody .. but .. well... after paying 240 $ for the service that's what I got, from a Semi-Govt agency in Singapore ..
+1!sundaymorningstaple wrote:In every other industry the Chinese are exactly the same way.JayCee wrote:
....indeed for the largest group (Indian - take a wild guess what kind of job I do) I get the impression that they would kick eachother's grandparents onto the street if it would get them a payrise or promotion.
"Budget Expat"
- nakatago
- Moderator
- Posts: 8358
- Joined: Tue, 01 Sep 2009 11:23 pm
- Location: Sister Margaret’s School for Wayward Children
I'm guessing some people are waiting for my reaction.
...unless I'm too lazy to do so.
- * Yes, the tribe mentality kinda gets in the way. But from what I gather, it's similar with Indians. That's why a lot of Filipinos dislike Indians--they see so much of them in them. I have seen the enemy and the enemy is us.
* Most Filipinos value sentimentality over what's right. It's freakin' annoying, especially if they're taking advantage of the kinship bordering on abuse and exploitation.
* "We stick together" only works if they see you as one of them. Filipinos, however, have no problems throwing another Filipino under a bus if they perceive him as different. This also happens a lot in other countries when relationships go south. That's how most Filipino illegal immigrants get caught--they stick together as fellow TNTs ("tago nang tago"--always hiding because they're illegal) until they have a disagreement and one of them tips off immigration officers.
* Filipinos don't take individuality from other Filipinos very well. Unless your very good looking, you'll be perceived as weird and should be avoided. NB: They make leeway for foreign-born/half-foreign Filipinos and rationalize them by "oh, he was raised in a different environment." But if you're born, bred and raised in the Philippines and you act different? You're a deviant, a pariah and a general bad person.
...unless I'm too lazy to do so.
"A quokka is what would happen if there was an anime about kangaroos."
- Strong Eagle
- Moderator
- Posts: 11504
- Joined: Sat, 10 Jul 2004 12:13 am
- Location: Off The Red Dot
- Contact:
Interesting that you mention this. My wife volunteers at aidha, teaching maids how to manage finance. She hears many stories of relatives back in the Philippines DEMANDING money from the working maid. My friend's maid didn't want to go back to visit family because all they did was pressure her for more money... even though she bought land, built a house that they are using.nakatago wrote:* Most Filipinos value sentimentality over what's right. It's freakin' annoying, especially if they're taking advantage of the kinship bordering on abuse and exploitation.
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
-
Landlord doesn’t agree to change occupants
by Harry1313 » Wed, 13 Mar 2019 9:59 pm » in Property Talk, Housing & Rental - 2 Replies
- 1746 Views
-
Last post by sheshen
Fri, 22 Mar 2019 12:54 pm
-
-
-
Retard NAS blogger trying to move here. Pray ICA sees sense and doesn't let him in.
by PNGMK » Sat, 23 Mar 2019 6:19 pm » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 14 Replies
- 4928 Views
-
Last post by x9200
Sun, 31 Mar 2019 11:57 am
-
-
-
What if candidate doesn't want to continue to work in SG after getting the EP
by Andyandy » Mon, 10 Feb 2020 10:11 pm » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 7 Replies
- 2305 Views
-
Last post by sundaymorningstaple
Thu, 13 Feb 2020 1:02 am
-
-
- 1 Replies
- 1573 Views
-
Last post by Haruki
Tue, 05 May 2020 7:07 pm
-
-
What is the expected EP Processing Time if encountered Public Holidays like Chinese New Year?
by richardlai » Mon, 26 Feb 2018 11:04 am » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 15 Replies
- 7441 Views
-
Last post by richardlai
Wed, 07 Mar 2018 6:10 pm
-
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests