I have to wonder if the original fans of XTC felt the same way after their more punk-ish beginnings ended around Black Sea, to be followed by the arguably best English Settlement, which is where I came in with them.JR8 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7bdfsYPp1Z4
The Stranglers - The Raven (Full Album)
Arguably my main formative band as a teenager, and this was arguably their final topping out as a band. They were punk, now with this album clearly new-wave, now light, too resolved.
They musically and compositionally grew up, and I think I and others lagged that, and pined for 'the Stranglers' that had been before that no longer existed, and wasn't coming back ...
Some bands evolve, some seem to just keep on going the same.Brah wrote:I have to wonder if the original fans of XTC felt the same way after their more punk-ish beginnings ended around Black Sea, to be followed by the arguably best English Settlement, which is where I came in with them.
Same for fans of the John Foxx/pre-Midge Ure-era Ultravox, to where I came in with them with Vienna, also arguably their best.
But I myself felt this way with my beloved Black Sabbath after Technical Ecstasy. and Pink Floyd after Animals.
I have a lot of grateful dead on my playlist, i had a neighbour in the eighties who used to to listen to a ton of grateful dead and led zep on tapes, but I was five and he was in his twenties, later when I am now in my thirties I decided to check them out and I quite enjoy several of their songs. I have to check out Phish though.Brah wrote:Worlds apart, Phish are /were the next Grateful Dead / jam band, DT were like the next Rush / Dregs / etc. but you know them.rajagainstthemachine wrote:I haven't heard Phish, but I assume they are a bit long as well? I have several friends who dislike DT because it puts them to sleep.nakatago wrote: Whose songs are longer: Dream Theater or Phish?
I am however an occasional listener, but I cannpt go through a whole DT album.
I too struggle with a whole DT album and prefer them song by song, though they put on a great, long concert, saw them a few times and while a lot of it sounds alike, it's well-put together stuff.
I don't think Phish have long songs, not like Yes or some other Prog Rock epics, just that live they jam on songs for a long time. Of what I've heard of Phish I really only like Billy Breathes and I like that a lot; I have another, studio album (probably missing the point with them) but don't like it.
Ayreon!! I think I had a friend recommend this to me I didn't get around to doing that and I think I will put this on my list to downloadBrah wrote:rajagainstthemachine wrote: Yeah I knew you wouldn't laugh, it was a self-deprecating comment, maybe I know the Star One still is borderline silly, but I still like it.
You might want to check out Arjen Lucassen's' regular' stuff with Ayreon,
I like Symphony X and Never heard of Shadow Gallery until nowBrah wrote:That Killswitch sounded pretty good.
One of the things in response to RITM for mindblowing-type solos was this at 6:00, the song after the 2 minute intro is pretty damn good, though by comparison sounds a bit old skool.
Shadow Gallery - Stiletto in the Sand / War for Sale
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ctj2u0vgGE
A better example, from 5:30
Symphony X - Accolade II
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Kb8SVgbzgM
Must be good with so many guys attempting this solo on YT, watching them do it shows how off-the-wall and technically challenging it is.
I recall being aware of but not hearing the Grateful Dead back in the 70's. With their name, album sleeves etc of skeletons, skulls, and constant references to drugs, I'd built up in my mind an image of them being a really heavy/psychedelic band.rajagainstthemachine wrote:I have a lot of grateful dead on my playlist, i had a neighbour in the eighties who used to to listen to a ton of grateful dead and led zep on tapes, but I was five and he was in his twenties, later when I am now in my thirties I decided to check them out and I quite enjoy several of their songs. I have to check out Phish though.
Well, in the 90's, there was a pop duo called Savage Garden and a boy band called Damage. When I found out what kind of music they performed, I was severely disappointed. Don't judge an album by its cover art.JR8 wrote:p.s. I actually, and this is hard for me to verbalise, find the overall proposition impenetrable, or perhaps rather offensive to sensibilities of mature and adult taste. Adult themes to such childish composition. Meanwhile, death-symbolism everywhere (their fans are called Deadheads right?) = Weird
I agree with you 100%, my first impressions were whoa!! this is badass,JR8 wrote:I recall being aware of but not hearing the Grateful Dead back in the 70's. With their name, album sleeves etc of skeletons, skulls, and constant references to drugs, I'd built up in my mind an image of them being a really heavy/psychedelic band.rajagainstthemachine wrote:I have a lot of grateful dead on my playlist, i had a neighbour in the eighties who used to to listen to a ton of grateful dead and led zep on tapes, but I was five and he was in his twenties, later when I am now in my thirties I decided to check them out and I quite enjoy several of their songs. I have to check out Phish though.
... so when I started to later get into heavy/psychedelic music in the early 80s I took the time to check them out, only to find that rather than being a hippy/stoner version of Black Sabbath, or similar, they're closer to Cliff Richard, er kinda doing a holiday special from some cutesy beach party... quite a shocker!
p.s. I actually, and this is hard for me to verbalise, find the overall proposition impenetrable, or perhaps rather offensive to sensibilities of mature and adult taste. Adult themes to such childish composition. Meanwhile, death-symbolism everywhere (their fans are called Deadheads right?) = Weird
--- The spice Girls achieved a lifetime (what, a year?) double the album sales of the Grateful Dead's entire career..... hnnnn
That is the one song on the album I could only listen to a few times. If that's all you heard, I can understand completely. And the albums that followed had a few listenable parts of songs, but their basic premise became unashamedly overindulgent to the point of comical. One of the "New Romantics" movement.JR8 wrote:Ultravox's Vienna. OMG. That self-indulgent dirge (IMHO) was #1 for weeks, I'd hope to never have to hear it ever again. I liked the earlier Ultravox prior to that.Brah wrote:I Ultravox, to where I came in with them with Vienna, also arguably their best.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests