fatmouse76 wrote:Which is better Tioman or Redang / I have never been snorkelling and dont know how to swim ,so hopefully they have some good divers there to show how to snorkel ..

I haven't been to both, so can only relay the thoughts of a trusted friend who thinks Redang over-developed, in it's own right, and certainly compared with Tioman. He rates the Perhentians higher than Redang, and suggested that I might enjoy them too.
One of the beauties of Tioman is it's accessibility. That was one of the main reasons for my suggesting it. You can do it for a weekend with minimal faffing about, transfers, uncertainty, etc. I.e. maximum stress-free bang for your buck. It is beautiful, the sea and the beaches and lovely people too, and so quiet... There are four Dash-7 flights a day (2 that are to/from KL, and 2 to/from SG)... I can walk to my usual dive centre from the airport... although with 20kgs of dive gear a 3 miunute van ride it certainly better.
If however you're asking if the diving is better in Tioaman than Redang, ah well that's another matter altogether! The diving is meant to be good in Redang... What I find with the east coast islands is that even in season (say end April to early October, tho it was a bit haywire this year) the conditions vary from location to location, day to day and even tide to tide. Enter the water from a beach and the visibility might be relatively low. Going out on a snorkelling boat might be a better idea, you see plenty of Asians doing that and you can be sure many of them also cannot swim. But anyone can float if you put a big enough snorkel jacket on them!
re: Firefly. When ever I have looked into their flight schedules I have been disappointed with how costly they are. So I've flown locally with AA, Jetstar and Tiger, but never been on Firefly. Also note KT is not Redang, you would then have to take a taxi/tfr to the port, and a ferry over to the islands. Many ferry times are not known until a day before... sometimes they change on the day itself. Not exactly a recipe for a relaxing weekend...
Good luck everyone...
p.s. I've been five times, and stayed in five hotels on those trips
- Swiss Cottage. End of Tekek beach. Used to be seriously basic, but they seem to have improved it somewhat since the close of the 2009 dive season. The en-suite showers now actually do work

. Only has room for circa 20 guests, booking a chalet on the top of the beach is bliss... sitting on the verandah watching the sea. I use the attached dive centre (Tioman dive Centre, who are very good).
- A place halfway between the airport and Swiss Cottage (say 750m)called Cheers Cottages or something very similar. Recently opened I think, right opposite the souvenir shop (who own the cottages). Only has about 6 rooms, and the bathroom facilities are shared, although they and the rooms are spotless. A double is only circa RM50 a night! Stayed here one time I couldn't get into Swiss. The showers use water piped straight down from the mountain... now I never did hot showers in SG or even tepid ones much at all, but I swear to god that these showers are amongst the coldest I have ever experienced anywhere in the world. I don't mean just doing the 'big inhale' in shock, I mean almost screaming!
- Berjaya. The largest resort on the island, though tastefully done I must say. Stayed here with my wife for the first night of our most recent trip (may '10) before moving to Swiss. Expensive but it sure looks comfortable.
- Japamala. Well, just check out TripAdvisor for the lowdown where it was ranked #1. Stayed here the first time we visited about 2006/2007. There were back then just 12 chalets I think. They were going to add a few more. It is a high-end boutique eco-resort. We stayed 4-5 days, and there were more staff than guests most days, though it was low season. Fantastic cooking, luckily, as essentially once you've done the boat transfer there (no roads, remember) (more luxury launch than simple boat, with twin 450hp outboards... far from eco, but phwoaaar

) you're probably not going to go anywhere else at all during your stay... lovely place for chilling, spa treatments, reading etc. Note at low tide the beach has some exposed reef-plate... so it is not ideal on the feet, and makes getting in/out the water very hard.