britexpat wrote:
True and Hong Kong and Macau have Michelin Guides due out at the beginning of next month, but you overlook the fact that the reason Michelin are only doing guides of Tokyo, Hong Kong and Macau is that Michelin thinks that they are the key cities that are worth looking at in the region. Why take criticism of food so personally, you can't live in a city anywhere that is perfect for everything.
Not really taking it personally, you are making quite deep analysis from a few lines, I was simply referring to your wrong framework for evaluating Singapore restaurants. I pretty well know that most of the mid priced so-called-western-food is quite bad, well to the level that I rather cook those things myself. But there are a lot of good Asian restaurants in different levels of pricing, and on the upper end good French and Italian ones. Of course this is a matter of personal taste.
But unless you work for the Michelin guide you guess for the reasons for the order of books is as good as mine. I would guess Michelin does the evaluations based on the size of cities and potential market to sell the book. Tokio and Hong Kong are bigger than Singapore, as simple as that. Will Macau really have it’s own book or is it together with HK? There are not too many books for cities less than 10 million people, so why would they do an exception to Singapore. If it will be covered it will probably be under other cities of Asia, like they did for Europe to give the smaller cities and countries a chance too.
Personally I think Michelin Guide Rouge is only useful in France, and even in France only outside Paris. In other places, it mainly guides you to the most expensive French or French style restaurants. But when driving in the French countryside and looking for an excellent regional restaurants, it is a great guide.
My personal favorite for evaluating culinary countries is the conservative but reliable CBP (Chirac-Berlusconi-Putin) old statesmen ranking. We’re know where UK is on that rank, but I can proudly say that my home country is even lower (Yes that is possible).
