It's rather funny, but it's not another culture, it's a product of lack of education and nothing more. Condi doesn't speak like that, neither did Martin Luther King, or Colin Powell nor do most people who finished school. What Culture are you talking about? (or did you really mean sub-culture?)Ecka Dimmock wrote:Althought the origin at the top is almost certainly false, the rest of this is pretty funny.
If you think Singlish is bad, it's worth remembering that other cultures also have nonstandard versions of English.
http://www.slurb.com/rfrancis/ebonics.html
Depends on what you mean by culture, I guess. Singlish is undoubtedly a product of Singapore, yet not all Singaporeans speak it. (You certainly don't hear Goh Chok Tong or LKY delivering speeches in it). In the US, there has been a serious move to use Ebonics as the medium of instruction in some schools, though this has been resisted by White and Black alike, as rather than removing social barriers it's likely to reinforce them.sundaymorningstaple wrote:It's rather funny, but it's not another culture, it's a product of lack of education and nothing more. Condi doesn't speak like that, neither did Martin Luther King, or Colin Powell nor do most people who finished school. What Culture are you talking about? (or did you really mean sub-culture?)Ecka Dimmock wrote:Althought the origin at the top is almost certainly false, the rest of this is pretty funny.
If you think Singlish is bad, it's worth remembering that other cultures also have nonstandard versions of English.
http://www.slurb.com/rfrancis/ebonics.html
sms
You are partially correct here. It's history is due to the fact that a drug pusher can earn more than a PhD in the gettos therefore a high dropout rate. The community is the getto's of the major american cities and the identity was due to no/low education so in order to talk with each other the language decended to the lowest common denominator. Just like your "Singlish" here. The lowest common denominator. The cream rises above this. But it is, in no way, the culture but a product of education or lack of in this case. (I have listened to the qualities of speech in neighbourhood schools English Programs here and am appalled {my son goes to one!} vrs upper class schools like CHIJ Toh Payoh where my daughter went to school) and the quality of teachers in innercity getto schools in the US are just the same except it's because everybody else is afraid to teach in those areas. Therefore the problem becomes self perpetuating.Ecka Dimmock wrote:By the way, I disagree that Black English is a product of "lack of education and nothing more". It has its own history, grammar and community, and like any dialect exists to create identity and group cohesion.
History? How so? Grammar? Puuuuleeeaaazzzee! it doe not have it's own grammar and was only mooted as a possible language option for education by whacko PC lefties who wanted to 'help' the black man. Yup, help him to NOT get a job, help him to NOT be able to communcate with anyone aside from their criminal 'brothers'.It has its own history, grammar
I don't enjoy rap music..but gosh! that lyric is outrageously demeaning and criminally illegal!jpatokal wrote:And along the same lines, here's a translation of 50 Cent's "In Da Club", including quotes from Cicero:
http://www.everything2.com/index.pl?node_id=1447155
Alamak, what a Singaporean reaction. If you don't like it, don't listen to it, instead of trying to stop everybody else from listening to it... is it any wonder there are no famous Singaporean bands and the whole bloody island's only cultural export is Annabel Chong?Ling2 wrote:I don't enjoy rap music..but gosh! that lyric is outrageously demeaning and criminally illegal!
Is there no law against it? To think that kids are listening to his music at a young age... It's a scary thought....
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests