jalanjalan wrote: ↑Thu, 04 May 2023 1:06 pm
Myasis Dragon wrote: ↑Thu, 04 May 2023 11:46 am
tiktok wrote: ↑Thu, 04 May 2023 11:01 am
But is the death penalty an effective deterrent? The crime rate in US states with death penalty is no lower than others. Hong Kong and Singapore have a similar murder rate but Hong Kong has no death penalty. Iran has even more severe drug laws but higher rates of drug abuse. There are endless anecdotes but little evidence.
As heartwarming as is to hear LKY and Shanmugan talking tough, it doesn't mean they are right.
I'm with you. Your statistics are correct. Worse, in the USA, the death penalty is applied in a way that puts more minorities on death row. It's very racist.
Beyond that, the death penalty is state-sanctioned murder. It's not a deterrent, it's state-sanctioned revenge It's bad enough that the death penalty is applied to capital crimes, it is abhorrent when applied to drug crimes. The death penalty is irrationally applied, imposed on some but not on others, with no valid justification for the difference.
Civilized countries have done away with the death penalty. If you want to put yourself in with China, Iran, Egypt, Syria, and Saudi Arabia, who are the top five executioners in the world, then keep the death penalty.
24 states and DC in the USA have abolished the death penalty, with 3 states having imposed a moratorium. Not surprisingly, the 24 states that all think the death penalty does some good are deep red republican states. Texas leads the killing.
The US justice system may well have made a mess of it, but that's their issue, not ours. Different country, different history, different population. They may do what they like within their own borders.
I like not seeing streets and streets of addicts lying in their own waste. I like that school children don't have to fend off dealers. What we're doing is clearly working for us. So I support it, and we may do what we like within our own borders.
You're doing a great job of exaggeration with "streets and streets of addicts lying in their own waste." And your callous disregard for human life is disturbing.
Here's an example of the Singapore death penalty: Tangaraju s/o Suppiah, 46, was executed on Wednesday 26 April 2023. Suppiah was sentenced to the mandatory death penalty in 2018 for assisting in the trafficking of 1,017g (35.9 ounces) of cannabis into Singapore in 2013.
ASSISTING in the import of 1 kilogram of pot, aka, marijuana. That is cruel and unusual punishment and death certainly doesn't fit the crime. 1 kilogram of pot is not a big time drug dealer.
You think that the death penalty is a deterrent? Then why were there 12 executions for drug trafficking in Singapore in 2022? It's barbaric.
And you think Singapore is not racist in its application of the death penalty. The statistics say otherwise.
Drug use and drug trafficking are a socio-economic issue, not a criminal issue.
https://transformativejusticecollective ... nt-system/
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/8/5 ... -for-drugs