PR approval chances 2022

[TanKianWee]

Hi All,

I would like to know my approval chances, I am planning to apply Singapore PR next year with my wife and my son. We have moved from Singapore to Malaysia since March 2020 till now close to 3 years residing in Malaysia, and I am work from home for Singapore company.

Hope that you can advise my chances.

Details :

My Profile:
Age : 39 (born in Year 1983)
Race : Malaysian Chinese
Gender : Male
Marital Status : Married
Religion : Buddhist
Education : Degree in Software Engineer (UK), Master Degree in Software Engineer (Malaysia) (Part Time)
Current Field of Work : Credit Services, Finance
Current Job : Associate Solution Engineer
Length of stay in Singapore : 2 Year 10 Months
No of tax return : Year 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 NOA
Salary Declared with IRAS 2022 Assessment : SGD69,197
Pass : EP (Renewed in 25 December 2019) (Second Time Renewing will be expiring in 23 April 2023)

My Wife:
Age : 40 (born in Year 1982)
Race : Burmese
Religion : Christian
Education : Primary School
Job : House wife

My Son:
Age : 2 (born in Year 2020)
Race : Malaysian Chinese
Gender : Male
Religion : Christian

Third Application Rejected Date : 29 June 2020
Application Date : 27 December 2019
Pending Interval : 6 Months 2 Days
Pass : EP
Remarks : ePR Application, Apply with my wife (Appointed Migration Agency to assist for submission)

Second Application Rejected Date : 13 May 2019
Application Date : 5 January 2019
Rejected Interval : 4 Months 8 Days
Pass : EP
Remarks : ePR Application, Only myself without applying with wife

First Application Rejected Date : 6 July 2018
Application Date : 6 December 2017
Rejected Interval : 7 Months
Pass : EP
Remarks : Manual Application, Only myself without applying with wife

[singaporeflyer]

Hi All,

I would like to know my approval chances, I am planning to apply Singapore PR next year with my wife and my son. We have moved from Singapore to Malaysia since March 2020 till now close to 3 years residing in Malaysia, and I am work from home for Singapore company.

Hope that you can advise my chances.

Details :

My Profile:
Age : 39 (born in Year 1983)
Race : Malaysian Chinese
Gender : Male
Marital Status : Married
Religion : Buddhist
Education : Degree in Software Engineer (UK), Master Degree in Software Engineer (Malaysia) (Part Time)
Current Field of Work : Credit Services, Finance
Current Job : Associate Solution Engineer
Length of stay in Singapore : 2 Year 10 Months
No of tax return : Year 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 NOA
Salary Declared with IRAS 2022 Assessment : SGD69,197
Pass : EP (Renewed in 25 December 2019) (Second Time Renewing will be expiring in 23 April 2023)

My Wife:
Age : 40 (born in Year 1982)
Race : Burmese
Religion : Christian
Education : Primary School
Job : House wife

My Son:
Age : 2 (born in Year 2020)
Race : Malaysian Chinese
Gender : Male
Religion : Christian

Third Application Rejected Date : 29 June 2020
Application Date : 27 December 2019
Pending Interval : 6 Months 2 Days
Pass : EP
Remarks : ePR Application, Apply with my wife (Appointed Migration Agency to assist for submission)

Second Application Rejected Date : 13 May 2019
Application Date : 5 January 2019
Rejected Interval : 4 Months 8 Days
Pass : EP
Remarks : ePR Application, Only myself without applying with wife

First Application Rejected Date : 6 July 2018
Application Date : 6 December 2017
Rejected Interval : 7 Months
Pass : EP
Remarks : Manual Application, Only myself without applying with wife

If you are residing in Malaysia and applying PR now, chance is close to 0

[TanKianWee]

Thanks singaporeflyer for your comment But not sure can I just try and see how is the outcome? And what if I residing back to Singapore like a year and apply again?

If you are residing in Malaysia and applying PR now, chance is close to 0

[gold.spot]

Try lor... If you were going to try anyway, asking here got no use one.

[MOCHS]

Treat the application fee as a donation and prepare for rejection until you decide to have a residential address in Singapore.

[therat]

Thanks singaporeflyer for your comment But not sure can I just try and see how is the outcome? And what if I residing back to Singapore like a year and apply again?

If you are residing in Malaysia and applying PR now, chance is close to 0

You can try, no one stopping you for trying.

no one know how long you need to stay in Singapore before you will get your PR.

BTW, not you only. your whole family.

[TanKianWee]

Thanks again all, gold.spot singaporeflyer MOCHS therat.

My EP just renewed and new expires on 23 April 2026. And my son, wife in the midst of processing the Dependant Pass. Hope the pass will get approved.

[nelyanne]

For your age and industry, the salary is very low, I would say that you were lucky to get the EP extended. There are other Malaysian Chinese with similar income who get the PR, but they are 10 years younger.

[sundaymorningstaple]

For your age and industry, the salary is very low, I would say that you were lucky to get the EP extended. There are other Malaysian Chinese with similar income who get the PR, but they are 10 years younger.

Age not too big of a handicap for Malaysian Chinese. I know one who was 50 and got S pass no issue. In fact Msian WP holders can be renewed up to age 60. Also renewal salaries are not the same as for other EP holders. Just like the entry level was about 1500/mo lower than other EP holders but you will not find it on the website. But it is a fact and it does exist. In fact we have had a few on here that also confirmed same.

[TanKianWee]

Hi nelyanne and sundaymorningstaple,
Thank you for your input.

Hi All,
My son dependant pass so fast got approved just in the same day approval, my company appointed agency submitted the DP application for wife and soon together on 3 November 2022 10:36am, I have checked about 3 times in between, my son DP pass approved on 3 November 202210:54pm which is about 12 hours time only... Maybe my son is a white paper and no record at all so fast got approved. However, my wife DP status is still pending.

Not sure anyone got experience before son got approved and wife is not approved?

And after got DP pass will that increase the PR application success rate?

[singaporeflyer]

Hi nelyanne and sundaymorningstaple,
Thank you for your input.

Hi All,
My son dependant pass so fast got approved just in the same day approval, my company appointed agency submitted the DP application for wife and soon together on 3 November 2022 10:36am, I have checked about 3 times in between, my son DP pass approved on 3 November 202210:54pm which is about 12 hours time only... Maybe my son is a white paper and no record at all so fast got approved. However, my wife DP status is still pending.

Not sure anyone got experience before son got approved and wife is not approved?

And after got DP pass will that increase the PR application success rate?

DP application can stil take its normal processing time. Your son's application approved in a few hours has no bearing that your wife's application must also be approved in the same processing time. DP approval has totally nothing related to PR approval.

[TanKianWee]

Thanks singaporeflyer for your input.

But my wife during submission the DP declaration.
I have put this statement because my wife got blacklist before in Malaysia. Not sure will that tough to get DP approved hmm... But my son DP got approved...

IN 2016, SPOUSE HELD A MALAYSIA STUDENT VISA AND WANTED TO APPLY FOR WORK PERMIT IN MALAYSIA. WAS IN THE PROCESS OF APPLYING MALAYSIA WORK PERMIT AND GOT CAUGHT BY MALAYSIA POLICE AS HER MALAYSIA STUDENT VISA HAS EXPIRED HENCE BEEN DEPORTED BACK TO MYANMAR FROM MALAYSIA IMMIGRATION. CURRENTLY RESIDING IN MALAYSIA HOLDING MALAYSIA SPOUSE VISA SINCE YEAR 2020.

Hi nelyanne and sundaymorningstaple,
Thank you for your input.

Hi All,
My son dependant pass so fast got approved just in the same day approval, my company appointed agency submitted the DP application for wife and soon together on 3 November 2022 10:36am, I have checked about 3 times in between, my son DP pass approved on 3 November 202210:54pm which is about 12 hours time only... Maybe my son is a white paper and no record at all so fast got approved. However, my wife DP status is still pending.

Not sure anyone got experience before son got approved and wife is not approved?

And after got DP pass will that increase the PR application success rate?

DP application can stil take its normal processing time. Your son's application approved in a few hours has no bearing that your wife's application must also be approved in the same processing time. DP approval has totally nothing related to PR approval.

[TanKianWee]

Hi All,

Thanks for your help and comment. Finally, my wife dependant pass have approved after 13 days of keep checking. Was so worry about the deported case from Malaysia Immigration and will causing the pass rejecting...

Just to highlight that only myself was stayed in Singapore from 23 May 2017 to 12 March 2020. Due to MCO in Malaysia, and we were planned to let our kid grow in Malaysia. Hence, the reason keep residing and work from home in Malaysia till now.
- From 13 March 2020 keep renting my Singapore room till Dec 2020
- From January 2021 till August 2021 was moved my items to storage

Now wish after the DP got issued for son and wife, then only submit the 4th time Singapore PR application. Really hope can get an approval this time...

Thanks singaporeflyer for your input.

But my wife during submission the DP declaration.
I have put this statement because my wife got blacklist before in Malaysia. Not sure will that tough to get DP approved hmm... But my son DP got approved...

IN 2016, SPOUSE HELD A MALAYSIA STUDENT VISA AND WANTED TO APPLY FOR WORK PERMIT IN MALAYSIA. WAS IN THE PROCESS OF APPLYING MALAYSIA WORK PERMIT AND GOT CAUGHT BY MALAYSIA POLICE AS HER MALAYSIA STUDENT VISA HAS EXPIRED HENCE BEEN DEPORTED BACK TO MYANMAR FROM MALAYSIA IMMIGRATION. CURRENTLY RESIDING IN MALAYSIA HOLDING MALAYSIA SPOUSE VISA SINCE YEAR 2020.

Hi nelyanne and sundaymorningstaple,
Thank you for your input.

Hi All,
My son dependant pass so fast got approved just in the same day approval, my company appointed agency submitted the DP application for wife and soon together on 3 November 2022 10:36am, I have checked about 3 times in between, my son DP pass approved on 3 November 202210:54pm which is about 12 hours time only... Maybe my son is a white paper and no record at all so fast got approved. However, my wife DP status is still pending.

Not sure anyone got experience before son got approved and wife is not approved?

And after got DP pass will that increase the PR application success rate?

DP application can stil take its normal processing time. Your son's application approved in a few hours has no bearing that your wife's application must also be approved in the same processing time. DP approval has totally nothing related to PR approval.