kwell,
I'm the same person as in the other forum. That's why it sounded like that.
Btw, aardvark, I don't think you should worry. Dr. Chuang has done nose jobs for many many years... since he was very young. Actually, he told me that my L implant will be placed under cartilage... not really sure what he meant by this.
But, anyway, there are MANY medical reports that claim that the L implant is still the best for Asians, generally. However, the L implant can be dangerous if the doctor makes mistakes such as wrong size and style choice, or incorrect trimming of the strut, bad placement, etc.
But, with a good doctor, there are FAR more successful cases with the L implant than bad cases.
If someone has opposing views or experiences, I welcome them... because afterall, many medical reports claim goretex over silicone, and many L over I or vice versa... not everyone agrees. However, I do think that going to a skilled doctor to do rib cartilage is the safest! And, hardly any doctor ever disagrees with that!
Good luck to everyone!