Everyone I know is leaving or already left

[Brah]

Am just taking the pulse here to see if others see this as well.

Nothing new, has been coming for a long time, but it has certainly accelerated.

[sundaymorningstaple]

After 33 years here, I can tell you, it's cyclic.

[Brah]

Well then this place in in the downward direction of a 10-12-year cycle

[sundaymorningstaple]

Of that, there is no doubt. But I've weathered them before. I ain't a quitter! lol

[JR8]

Just for the record, as one data point, we didn't leave because we chose to as such, it was just that the time to get posted out again came up. We might return to SG once more, but that decision will x-over with the option of taking early retirement back to London (after c12 years away at the end of this posting).... so we'll see.

Now if they were to x-post us to somewhere top-notch, like NYC, then all bets are off for agreeing to one last hurrah

[Brah]

Of that, there is no doubt. But I've weathered them before. I ain't a quitter! lol

It has nothing to do with quitting. If I was smarter than I am I would have left long ago.

[Strong Eagle]

The real danger for expats these days is for those who are not on PR. When the economy is robust and there are normal rounds of hiring and retrenchment, 30 days seems OK.

But when entire industries downsize or offshore, three things happen, all bad. There's a flood of EP's, all looking for work. There's a lack of jobs because they've all left Singapore. And all of a sudden, 30 days becomes a death sentence for future residency in Singapore.

There is no security anymore.

[BBCWatcher]

The real danger for expats these days is for those who are not on PR.

A PEP also works pretty well, especially if well timed.

[bgd]

The real danger for expats these days is for those who are not on PR.

A PEP also works pretty well, especially if well timed.

Agreed, but it's one shot. Mine expires next year.

[martincymru]

Housing is the main issue.

If you are a western expat, will share a room and accept 3k salary then lots of jobs here. Otherwise (and I guess most of you are "otherwise") it's tough unless you have skill an Asian cannot do.

[rajagainstthemachine]

mine's been renewed as we speak, i expect no dramas though.

[BBCWatcher]

Agreed, but it's one shot.

True, but if living in Singapore means coping with multiple, frequent bouts of extended unemployment then maybe it's time to shove off and move out anyway. PR status only gives you the option to suffer multiple, frequent income losses, not the obligation.

Metaphorically speaking, if you live in Syria or Yemen (as examples) then one bomb landing in your backyard you might consider a fluke, but the second one the day after ought to be treated as a commandment.

[BBCWatcher]

But when entire industries downsize or offshore, three things happen, all bad.

I agree with you, but while it's bad for foreign workers it's working exactly as the government wants for resident workers. The foreign workers are supposed to be the "gap fillers," the "swing" workforce -- the temporary hired help. If they bear the brunt of economic downturns then resident workers will bear much less. Moreover, any economic downturns will occur within the context of a government that is trying to slow down population growth, amplifying the impacts. There is some "good" in that for remaining foreign workers looking to become resident workers. The fewer EPs applying for PR, the greater the chance each applicant has of approval assuming that the annual PR quota is static. (It certainly seems to be.) As a metaphor, when the dinosaurs died out the little proto-rodents hung on (and dined on dinosaur carcasses, probably), thrived, and eventually evolved to become humans. If you're one of the survivors you can do well.

For what it's worth, my anecdotal evidence adds up to "stability," for now. Maybe my professional circle(s) are doing better than average. That said, it's obvious there are some industries that are not doing well, notably O&G (oil and gas). But the transportation sector, especially the airlines, do quite well when energy prices are low, and there is some evidence that's true in Singapore, too.

I would caution that you will inevitably see lots of people leaving if you're one of the "survivors," even in comparatively good economic conditions. All people leave eventually since all people are mortal. (Well, at least I've never met anybody who credibly claims otherwise.) So when you get old, either in residence or age terms, you naturally notice lots of people around you dropping out and dying off. It's just how it goes, and it's "survivor's observational bias."

[PNGMK]

I would caution that you will inevitably see lots of people leaving if you're one of the "survivors," even in comparatively good economic conditions. All people leave eventually if for no other reason that all people are mortal.

Truer words.

[Addadude]

All people leave eventually since all people are mortal. (Well, at least I've never met anybody who credibly claims otherwise.)

I dunno. I'm beginning to think SMS is Lazarus Man.