SINGAPORE EXPATS FORUM
Singapore Expat Forum and Message Board for Expats in Singapore & Expatriates Relocating to Singapore
EP Rejection and new application - please help
EP Rejection and new application - please help
I would really appreciate some help!
I know it is hard to predict an outcome that the Ministry of Manpower may make, but I do really need some opinions from people with personal experience.
I am applying for a role with a well established international financial services company in Singapore as a Business Manager.
1.The salary will be S$15-18K/month.
2. I do not have a completed university degree
3. I do have a recognised Advanced Diploma and relevant work experience of 8+ years and am a member of the Australian Institute of Management.
4. I have worked for this organisation in the past in Australia. I have never worked in Singapore.
What are the chances that I will be approved given I do not have a degree?
I don't know whether to go for this position or wait to finish my Masters degree. I have already been rejected a couple of months ago for a role with the same organisations in Singapore so don't want to burn bridges and I'm not sure if I should wait. Since been rejected, I have since gained the previous mentioned qualifications.
My EP was rejected for the previous role because 1. Lack of qualifications for role 2. Salary does not seem commensurate with experience
I'm Australian, the role was paying S$19K.
Because it was a 6-month contract role, the employer decided not to appeal even though since the rejection I have received an Advanced Diploma in a related area.
I know it is hard to predict an outcome that the Ministry of Manpower may make, but I do really need some opinions from people with personal experience.
I am applying for a role with a well established international financial services company in Singapore as a Business Manager.
1.The salary will be S$15-18K/month.
2. I do not have a completed university degree
3. I do have a recognised Advanced Diploma and relevant work experience of 8+ years and am a member of the Australian Institute of Management.
4. I have worked for this organisation in the past in Australia. I have never worked in Singapore.
What are the chances that I will be approved given I do not have a degree?
I don't know whether to go for this position or wait to finish my Masters degree. I have already been rejected a couple of months ago for a role with the same organisations in Singapore so don't want to burn bridges and I'm not sure if I should wait. Since been rejected, I have since gained the previous mentioned qualifications.
My EP was rejected for the previous role because 1. Lack of qualifications for role 2. Salary does not seem commensurate with experience
I'm Australian, the role was paying S$19K.
Because it was a 6-month contract role, the employer decided not to appeal even though since the rejection I have received an Advanced Diploma in a related area.
Benny
Yes. I am yet to hear about someone to be rejected at those salary levels.
Also that fact that salary too high being a factor for rejection is something very new.
At those salary levels you didn't have to have qualifications, until now. I know they are tightening, but somehow, your case seems too harsh. I suspect, your employer might have abused work visas in the past. Does your employer have too many foreigners as a ratio of the total staff? This could be the biggest reason.
My suggestion, make your employer appeal and ask them to make a very compelling case to justify why they need to hire and pay you that much. Or simply try another employer. If someone wants to pay you that high, I am sure, your skills are in high demand.
Don't give up, that's how things work here these days, lots of persuasion needed compared to what used to be a 1 day affair to get an EP in the past. Earlier they were too lax and now to compensate they are getting too stringent and going overboard with it.
Also that fact that salary too high being a factor for rejection is something very new.
At those salary levels you didn't have to have qualifications, until now. I know they are tightening, but somehow, your case seems too harsh. I suspect, your employer might have abused work visas in the past. Does your employer have too many foreigners as a ratio of the total staff? This could be the biggest reason.
My suggestion, make your employer appeal and ask them to make a very compelling case to justify why they need to hire and pay you that much. Or simply try another employer. If someone wants to pay you that high, I am sure, your skills are in high demand.
Don't give up, that's how things work here these days, lots of persuasion needed compared to what used to be a 1 day affair to get an EP in the past. Earlier they were too lax and now to compensate they are getting too stringent and going overboard with it.
thanks for your response. I like you assumed it would be simple as 123 because the employer has a very good reputation and very strong returns and hugh capital. In fact, I made the silly mistake of packing up, giving up a permanent job in Australia that I had just accepted for this dream job and flew over to Singapore only to find out the next morning of arrival that my application was rejected and I was not provided any reimbursement.
I suspect the salary seemed high because of my age being only early 30s with no degree and my previous salaries being considerably lower. having said that the rate was negotiated based on the equivalent of a day-rate in a comparable contract role in Australia. I have proven experience in establishing new departments and processes and have trained MBA graduates so it's quiet ironic and a shock because we aren't so focused on qualifications in Aus rather on a candidates ability to actually deliver value to the business.
I cannot appeal the rejection - it's too late for that as they have employed someone else - a local. The question now is whether I pursue the new opportunity or continue working in Aus until I confer a degree and try and pursue opportunities at such time in Singapore.
I really really want to live and work in Singapore - I hate being back here
I suspect the salary seemed high because of my age being only early 30s with no degree and my previous salaries being considerably lower. having said that the rate was negotiated based on the equivalent of a day-rate in a comparable contract role in Australia. I have proven experience in establishing new departments and processes and have trained MBA graduates so it's quiet ironic and a shock because we aren't so focused on qualifications in Aus rather on a candidates ability to actually deliver value to the business.
I cannot appeal the rejection - it's too late for that as they have employed someone else - a local. The question now is whether I pursue the new opportunity or continue working in Aus until I confer a degree and try and pursue opportunities at such time in Singapore.
I really really want to live and work in Singapore - I hate being back here

Benny
- sundaymorningstaple
- Moderator
- Posts: 39766
- Joined: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 1:26 pm
- Location: Retired on the Little Red Dot
The role may not have called for someone at that level of payscale (in their eyes). So it might have looked like something of a ruse just to get you on the payroll (with possibly a kickback to the employer - probably not the case, but it's a ruse that has be tried and tried again. So, they tend to err on the side of caution. Or they felt pretty sure that there were suitably qualified locals that would be able to fill the position. As, it would seem, was the case. Therefore, they were justified in the rejection as the position WAS filled by a local. It is getting rough here. At all levels.
SOME PEOPLE TRY TO TURN BACK THEIR ODOMETERS. NOT ME. I WANT PEOPLE TO KNOW WHY I LOOK THIS WAY. I'VE TRAVELED A LONG WAY, AND SOME OF THE ROADS WEREN'T PAVED. ~ Will Rogers
how long before you finish your degree? is it relevant to the area you wish to be/remain in? is it from a school that is recognized by singapore (mom/moe etc)?aus-sing wrote:...The question now is whether I pursue the new opportunity or continue working in Aus until I confer a degree and try and pursue opportunities at such time in Singapore.
Aut viam ad caelum inveniam aut faciam
Hi aus-sing, and welcome to the forum.
A few thoughts/comments...
If you were applying for a full time job at that pay level it would be a P1 EP (visa). For that level being a graduate is not a requirement. I don’t know what kind of visa you are applying for though, do you?
How do you go from an Advanced Diploma to a Masters? Wouldn’t there normally be an undergraduate course in between?
Your chances? They depend upon things like how much ‘foreigner quota’ the hiring company have. That aside if you’re being paid that $ one has to imagine the hiring company think you’re qualified for it!
Whether to interrupt your Masters is another matter. Short term $ gain, versus any virtue derived from having that qualification on your resume. Can you suspend your studies whilst here?
I think rejection due to quals is a red herring, especially considering 8+ years experience. There is a recognised concept of ‘Qualified by experience’, particularly at the P1 level (how I got in here 1st time around). The local HR is perhaps the best one to try and interpret the previous rejection.
Best of luck.
A few thoughts/comments...
If you were applying for a full time job at that pay level it would be a P1 EP (visa). For that level being a graduate is not a requirement. I don’t know what kind of visa you are applying for though, do you?
How do you go from an Advanced Diploma to a Masters? Wouldn’t there normally be an undergraduate course in between?
Your chances? They depend upon things like how much ‘foreigner quota’ the hiring company have. That aside if you’re being paid that $ one has to imagine the hiring company think you’re qualified for it!
Whether to interrupt your Masters is another matter. Short term $ gain, versus any virtue derived from having that qualification on your resume. Can you suspend your studies whilst here?
I think rejection due to quals is a red herring, especially considering 8+ years experience. There is a recognised concept of ‘Qualified by experience’, particularly at the P1 level (how I got in here 1st time around). The local HR is perhaps the best one to try and interpret the previous rejection.
Best of luck.
Thanks for the welcome and insight JR8. I cannot begin to express how stressful my first experience was - waiting around in a country after I had packed up everything and trying to get answers from the agency and employer about an appeal.JR8 wrote:Hi aus-sing, and welcome to the forum.
A few thoughts/comments...
If you were applying for a full time job at that pay level it would be a P1 EP (visa). For that level being a graduate is not a requirement. I don’t know what kind of visa you are applying for though, do you?
How do you go from an Advanced Diploma to a Masters? Wouldn’t there normally be an undergraduate course in between?
Your chances? They depend upon things like how much ‘foreigner quota’ the hiring company have. That aside if you’re being paid that $ one has to imagine the hiring company think you’re qualified for it!
Whether to interrupt your Masters is another matter. Short term $ gain, versus any virtue derived from having that qualification on your resume. Can you suspend your studies whilst here?
I think rejection due to quals is a red herring, especially considering 8+ years experience. There is a recognised concept of ‘Qualified by experience’, particularly at the P1 level (how I got in here 1st time around). The local HR is perhaps the best one to try and interpret the previous rejection.
Best of luck.
The agency applied for an EP and S pass.
I'm not worried about interrupting my masters. They have block-mode and online options as well as the flexibility to defer.
Regarding entering a Masters program without an undergraduate degree, it is possible in most Masters degrees in Australia if you have relevant professional experience, although they usually ask you to start with a Graduate Certificate and continue to diploma and masters if you attain a minimum of a credit average.
Benny
OMG!
I just re-read the submission the agency maid for my EP application (which was rejected). And look what I noticed under Industry Carification
In Step 2 Application iNFORMATION, Section C b) Industry Classification: MAID AGENCIES
Could this be the reason my application was rejected?
It's a management role for an international FI!
I just re-read the submission the agency maid for my EP application (which was rejected). And look what I noticed under Industry Carification
In Step 2 Application iNFORMATION, Section C b) Industry Classification: MAID AGENCIES
Could this be the reason my application was rejected?
It's a management role for an international FI!
Benny
On the hop right now, haven't read past para 1 of your reply, but first thing...
S Pass... ? On say $200kpa !? WTH were they thinking!?
------------------------------
'S Pass The S Pass allows mid-level skilled foreigners who earn a fixed monthly salary of at least $2,200 to work in Singapore. Employers must make S Pass applications on behalf of a job candidate. S Pass applications are assessed on multiple criteria including salary, education qualification, skills, job type and work experience. read more - See more at: http://www.mom.gov.sg/foreign-manpower/ ... CBk4T.dpuf
-------------------------------
S Pass... ? On say $200kpa !? WTH were they thinking!?

------------------------------
'S Pass The S Pass allows mid-level skilled foreigners who earn a fixed monthly salary of at least $2,200 to work in Singapore. Employers must make S Pass applications on behalf of a job candidate. S Pass applications are assessed on multiple criteria including salary, education qualification, skills, job type and work experience. read more - See more at: http://www.mom.gov.sg/foreign-manpower/ ... CBk4T.dpuf
-------------------------------
- nakatago
- Moderator
- Posts: 8358
- Joined: Tue, 01 Sep 2009 11:23 pm
- Location: Sister Margaret’s School for Wayward Children
JR8 wrote:aus-sing wrote:OMG! I just re-read the submission the agency maid ...
In Step 2 Application iNFORMATION, Section C b) Industry Classification: MAID AGENCIES
Could this be the reason my application was rejected?
It's a management role for an international FI!
![]()
![]()
Just slightly
Well, THERE'S your problem!
"A quokka is what would happen if there was an anime about kangaroos."
I wonder whether there humans approving/rejecting EP applications or machines.aus-sing wrote:OMG!
I just re-read the submission the agency maid for my EP application (which was rejected). And look what I noticed under Industry Carification
In Step 2 Application iNFORMATION, Section C b) Industry Classification: MAID AGENCIES
Could this be the reason my application was rejected?
It's a management role for an international FI!
I mean, imagine name of the employer "ANZ Singapore LTD" salary 15K and if the industry classification is Maid Agency, even a high school boy will know its an error. Considering the Justifications given, the person who handled your case at MoM was really dumb, if he/she was a person, that is.
Last edited by Wd40 on Fri, 29 Aug 2014 12:24 pm, edited 2 times in total.
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
-
Citizenship Application Rejection Letter
by ultratech » Sat, 28 Nov 2020 11:20 am » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 39 Replies
- 11782 Views
-
Last post by malcontent
Thu, 03 Dec 2020 11:57 pm
-
-
-
Rejection of EP Application due to experience certificate
by SuhasRao2304 » Mon, 22 Mar 2021 4:09 pm » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 2 Replies
- 1753 Views
-
Last post by shaym
Thu, 27 May 2021 4:33 pm
-
-
-
Student pass rejection - HELP!
by blockster03 » Tue, 13 Sep 2022 3:42 pm » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 5 Replies
- 688 Views
-
Last post by nelyanne
Tue, 13 Sep 2022 9:13 pm
-
-
-
Appeal for EP rejection chance and extend stvp ?
by jakejungle » Wed, 22 Jul 2020 11:32 pm » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 17 Replies
- 6470 Views
-
Last post by Raghuram
Fri, 09 Oct 2020 8:47 pm
-
-
-
PR Rejection 2021 and thinking ahead about my daughters future
by NekshaanIrani » Sun, 10 Oct 2021 1:57 pm » in PR, Citizenship, Passes & Visas for Foreigners - 4 Replies
- 2126 Views
-
Last post by PNGMK
Sat, 06 Nov 2021 1:54 pm
-
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests