Strong Eagle wrote:JR8 wrote:Imagine the SG government sanctioning LIDL opening a supermarket here. It would be bedlam, 30c beer and $9 Canadian lobsters!!!

But (exhale), it's ok, they'd never let it happen...
And with good reason.
You managed to veer right around the elephant in the room, to get up on your political soap-box there
Supermarkets here are owned/franchised by the state. There is little or no 'pricing pressure', i.e. competition. You're suggesting that's a good thing, but in whose interests is it? It's akin to arguing that evolution is somehow morally wrong.
Walmart got expelled from Germany due to the same views you're espousing. 'We can't have these rabid capitalists (dirty Americans, spit spit!!) coming in and under-cutting the good Germans who run the corner-shop apothecary. Hell nein!, far better we all pay euro$1 per Asparin! Zis ist ein sozial duty!'.
One could argue that it is all rather like trying to hold back the tide, like perpetually breeding pandas in the face of them being a 'failed species'. There are places where enforced but happy-mediums exist.
Marylebone High Street London. Owned by one family. They dictated the policy of who they will let to. As a result it's chain-free, but also $$$ and pretty high-end. Not too many poor people hanging out in that neighbourhood!
They did or tried to do similar with Kensington Church Street...
Many regional small towns in the UK, they allow new 'out-of-town supermarkets' but it is zoned with the aim that they will co-exist with in-town shops, rather than compete to the death. => Freedom of choice.
I think the concept of a city having a derelict/dangerous (killed-off) downtown, and a wealthier peripheral suburbia is perhaps a uniquely American thing. What's the phenomena called... something like donutization! What to blame, Henry Ford or crack cocaine?
p.s. I remember when there was one telecom company in the UK. You had to rent your handset from the company, and call charges were outrageous. Then the government floated/IPOd it... bam! calling the US went from say £1/min to 1p/min. Bad? The same was done with all utilities, gas, elec, water. Everyone benefited from the resulting competition. Competition is often good for a system; consider 'survival of the fittest' and a coral ecosystem.
vs - Look who owns all the utils and supermarkets here ... ...