Do I stand a Chance getting SC :)

singh86 · Post by **singh86** » Tue, 24 Jun 2014 12:33 pm

I've been living and working in Singapore from 2006, PR from last 5 years and just got mine and my wife's REP renewed

Indian
Salary: $5000+
Education : Degree
Singapore PR Since 2009
Married to Malaysian also Singapore PR, Wife Working & earning around $2.5k

I want to apply for SC for myself. Not sure if I stand a chance

Appreciate your positive comments.

No nasty, racist and against foreigners comments pls

{Reinstated by moderator}

Post by **nakatago** » Tue, 24 Jun 2014 12:43 pm

Wait for another REP renewal.

#obligatory_singapore_doesnt_want_indians_comment

the lynx · Post by **the lynx** » Tue, 24 Jun 2014 1:14 pm

singh86 wrote:I've been living and working in Singapore from 2006, PR from last 5 years and just got mine and my wife's REP renewed

Indian
Salary: $5000+
Education : Degree
Singapore PR Since 2009
Married to Malaysian also Singapore PR, Wife Working & earning around $2.5k

I want to apply for SC for myself. Not sure if I stand a chance

Appreciate your positive comments.

No nasty, racist and against foreigners comments pls

Why not together with her as well? Your application forms require her details and documents anyway.

And I think you should wait for 2 REP renewals before considering to apply.

So while you're looking for positive comments, I can only say that your chance is negative. Sorry.

singh86 · Post by **singh86** » Tue, 24 Jun 2014 2:42 pm

My wife PR not yet 2 yrs that's why

Thanks for your valuable input

the lynx wrote:
singh86 wrote:I've been living and working in Singapore from 2006, PR from last 5 years and just got mine and my wife's REP renewed

Indian
Salary: $5000+
Education : Degree
Singapore PR Since 2009
Married to Malaysian also Singapore PR, Wife Working & earning around $2.5k

I want to apply for SC for myself. Not sure if I stand a chance

Appreciate your positive comments.

No nasty, racist and against foreigners comments pls
Why not together with her as well? Your application forms require her details and documents anyway.

And I think you should wait for 2 REP renewals before considering to apply.

So while you're looking for positive comments, I can only say that your chance is negative. Sorry.

singh86 · Post by **singh86** » Tue, 24 Jun 2014 5:18 pm

Thanks for your feedback.. Sure Singapore wants educated and well mannered Indians

nakatago wrote:Wait for another REP renewal.

#obligatory_singapore_doesnt_want_indians_comment

Saint · Post by **Saint** » Tue, 24 Jun 2014 5:31 pm

Do you own a HDB?

Saint · Post by **Saint** » Tue, 24 Jun 2014 5:46 pm

Emergency123 wrote:
Saint wrote:Do you own a HDB?
Why is that relevant ?

Very relevant

the lynx · Post by **the lynx** » Wed, 25 Jun 2014 8:32 am

Saint wrote:
Emergency123 wrote:
Saint wrote:Do you own a HDB?
Why is that relevant ?
Very relevant

Actually I would like to know why too. Didn't know HDB ownership has something in play in this...

Saint · Post by **Saint** » Wed, 25 Jun 2014 8:42 am

the lynx wrote:
Saint wrote:
Emergency123 wrote: Why is that relevant ?
Very relevant
Actually I would like to know why too. Didn't HDB ownership has something in play in this...

If they don't already own a HDB I'm guessing they want to but with the new 3 year PR rule that came in last August they now don't qualify for at least another year or so. Therefore to get around this the OP wants to try for Citizenship which will allow them to buy a HDB. The Gahmen will realise this as there's been a flood of Citizenship applications since the new rule.

If they already own a HDB then his chances are higher of being successful.

zzm9980 · Post by **zzm9980** » Thu, 26 Jun 2014 6:24 am

Emergency123 wrote:
Saint wrote:
the lynx wrote: Actually I would like to know why too. Didn't HDB ownership has something in play in this...
If they don't already own a HDB I'm guessing they want to but with the new 3 year PR rule that came in last August they now don't qualify for at least another year or so. Therefore to get around this the OP wants to try for Citizenship which will allow them to buy a HDB. The Gahmen will realise this as there's been a flood of Citizenship applications since the new rule.

If they already own a HDB then his chances are higher of being successful.
Buying a house does not seem like a good reason to want citizenship of a country!

Maybe for you. But for many people who do come to Singapore from other less prosperous locations financial benefits are the primary driver. You can try to tell the official at ICA nicely that you're not one of those people and maybe they'll take your word for it.

Post by **sundaymorningstaple** » Thu, 26 Jun 2014 10:07 am

If they have to wait 3 years to buy a resale flat as a PR, once the get SC they can buy new from the HDB without any waiting period (provided they can find one to buy where they desire) with the subsidies available to Citizens as well. Considerable savings then.

singh86 · Post by **singh86** » Fri, 27 Jun 2014 1:01 pm

I do not own HDB but I own a condo in fact 2 condos one top 2016

Saint wrote:
the lynx wrote:
Saint wrote: Very relevant
Actually I would like to know why too. Didn't HDB ownership has something in play in this...
If they don't already own a HDB I'm guessing they want to but with the new 3 year PR rule that came in last August they now don't qualify for at least another year or so. Therefore to get around this the OP wants to try for Citizenship which will allow them to buy a HDB. The Gahmen will realise this as there's been a flood of Citizenship applications since the new rule.

If they already own a HDB then his chances are higher of being successful.

Post by **PNGMK** » Fri, 27 Jun 2014 1:11 pm

Won't help but won't hinder.

singh86 wrote:I do not own HDB but I own a condo in fact 2 condos one top 2016

Saint wrote:
the lynx wrote: Actually I would like to know why too. Didn't HDB ownership has something in play in this...
If they don't already own a HDB I'm guessing they want to but with the new 3 year PR rule that came in last August they now don't qualify for at least another year or so. Therefore to get around this the OP wants to try for Citizenship which will allow them to buy a HDB. The Gahmen will realise this as there's been a flood of Citizenship applications since the new rule.

If they already own a HDB then his chances are higher of being successful.

Wd40 · Post by **Wd40** » Fri, 27 Jun 2014 1:37 pm

singh86 wrote:I do not own HDB but I own a condo in fact 2 condos one top 2016

Got rich dad in Punjab, Delhi or whatever place in North India is it?

Post by **sundaymorningstaple** » Fri, 27 Jun 2014 1:53 pm

singh86,

Sadly, all you have succeeded in accomplishing by deleting your opening post, is showing us, once again, why a lot of you are so despised here. Trying to erase your tracks after you didn't the the answer you wanted is childish, to say the least. We have a lot of long time Indian regulars here who are just as aggravated at the attitudes of their countrymen as the rest of us. This is why we've gotten into the habit of quoting the opening post so the thread doesn't turn to garbage, thereby leaving only the OP to look like garbage.

moderator

SINGAPORE EXPATS FORUM
Singapore Expat Forum and Message Board for Expats in Singapore & Expatriates Relocating to Singapore

Do I stand a Chance getting SC :)

Do I stand a Chance getting SC :)

Re: Do I stand a Chance getting SC :)

Re: Do I stand a Chance getting SC :)

Who is online