If you almost finished the change when it happened how the other car could hit any part of your right side? Not seeing the actual damage it's hard to tell but if this is side-back damage it looks like you were at fault.AdviceNeeded wrote:I was driving along Bukit Timah road on the early morning. It is three lane road and I was driving on the second road and intend to change lane to the first lane. After checking carefully, there was no car on my right. I was almost finishing the changing, and a car hit on the rear right (including side) portion of my car. No injury in the accident.
The opposite side asked me to be 100% responsible for the accident. but I still think that the other side should be responsible for the accident, at least partially. Can anyone give me advice? Your suggestion would be appreciated greatly.
I gave enough signal, and the damage was a scratch from the rear wheel to the rear corner. Is this my 100% fault? Thanks a lot.x9200 wrote:If you almost finished the change when it happened how the other car could hit any part of your right side? Not seeing the actual damage it's hard to tell but if this is side-back damage it looks like you were at fault.
I gave enough signal. I intended to change to the first lane as the second lane was congested then.Beeroclock wrote:it's rare to have 100% responsibility. especially if he hit you from behind, he needs to take at least partial, if not majority responsibility. Did you indicate ? What was your reason for changing lanes ?
Thank you. The other side claimed that I was changing lane, and he was driving in his own lane, then it was totally my fault.taxico wrote:not much you can do as your description of the accident is sketchy. a car can't materialize out of no where into your blind spot.
just report it and hope for the best - ie, the other driver was driving recklessly, or the usual "almost no fault if your butt got hit in singapore" scenario, or... that other car has no dash cam!
3 lane street, you are in the middle lane turning to the right (to the most right lane). There is no space further to the right as this is only a 3 lane street. If you were hit also from the right side it means the other car was not at your rare but to your right already some time before you finished. It had to fit the space between your car and the curb, so unlikely it was at the time you were about to finish the maneuver. it is not a classical back-hit incident.AdviceNeeded wrote:I gave enough signal, and the damage was a scratch from the rear wheel to the rear corner. Is this my 100% fault? Thanks a lot.x9200 wrote:If you almost finished the change when it happened how the other car could hit any part of your right side? Not seeing the actual damage it's hard to tell but if this is side-back damage it looks like you were at fault.
I tend to agree, other driver has right of way in his own lane. If you finish changing lanes and he hits you from behind then that's different. But if you are in process of changing lanes and collide on the side (even if rear/side) then it sounds "primarily" your fault.x9200 wrote:I don't know whether you were 100% at fault but IMHO you could be for a significant part of it.
Thank you so much.x9200 wrote:3 lane street, you are in the middle lane turning to the right (to the most right lane). There is no space further to the right as this is only a 3 lane street. If you were hit also from the right side it means the other car was not at your rare but to your right already some time before you finished. It had to fit the space between your car and the curb, so unlikely it was at the time you were about to finish the maneuver. it is not a classical back-hit incident.
I don't know whether you were 100% at fault but IMHO you could be for a significant part of it.
Thank you for your comments.Beeroclock wrote:I tend to agree, other driver has right of way in his own lane. If you finish changing lanes and he hits you from behind then that's different. But if you are in process of changing lanes and collide on the side (even if rear/side) then it sounds "primarily" your fault.
it sounds like a very minor accident. why not contact him to settle it privately after filing your accident report?AdviceNeeded wrote:...the damage was a scratch from the rear wheel to the rear corner. Is this my 100% fault? Thanks a lot.
"Gave enough signal"???AdviceNeeded wrote:I gave enough signal, and the damage was a scratch from the rear wheel to the rear corner. Is this my 100% fault? Thanks a lot.x9200 wrote:If you almost finished the change when it happened how the other car could hit any part of your right side? Not seeing the actual damage it's hard to tell but if this is side-back damage it looks like you were at fault.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest