Specifically with Malays and Dogs the issue is a poor interpretation of the PM (PBUH) command about dogs being unclean. I have plenty of friends in other countries who are muslims and have pet dogs (although in all fairness they tend to keep them outside but so do I).Sergei82 wrote:What's the issue with Muslims and dogs??? I noticed Malays prefer cats, but I didn't think it is bcuz of Islam vs dogs issues...
Btw, explanation of why dogs preferred in HDB compared to cats is plain dumb and incomprehensible for me. Cats are BY FAR much cleaner than dogs (its in their instinct).
Google on 'islam dogs malaysia' if you want some in-depth version.Sergei82 wrote:What's the issue with Muslims and dogs??? I noticed Malays prefer cats, but I didn't think it is bcuz of Islam vs dogs issues...
It's Islam. Apparently the saliva of a dog is impure however you can keep a working (hunting) dog and although it will get saliva on whatever it kills that does not make the meat impure and you can still eat it.Sergei82 wrote:What's the issue with Muslims and dogs??? I noticed Malays prefer cats, but I didn't think it is bcuz of Islam vs dogs issues...
Btw, explanation of why dogs preferred in HDB compared to cats is plain dumb and incomprehensible for me. Cats are BY FAR much cleaner than dogs (its in their instinct).
http://www.hdb.gov.sg/fi10/fi10326p.nsf ... enDocumentSergei82 wrote:Btw, explanation of why dogs preferred in HDB compared to cats is plain dumb and incomprehensible for me. Cats are BY FAR much cleaner than dogs (its in their instinct).
Maybe because you'll clean and cook the meat. You're not going to clean and/or cook your hand or your face when a dog slobbers all over you?Steve1960 wrote:It's Islam. Apparently the saliva of a dog is impure however you can keep a working (hunting) dog and although it will get saliva on whatever it kills that does not make the meat impure and you can still eat it.Sergei82 wrote:What's the issue with Muslims and dogs??? I noticed Malays prefer cats, but I didn't think it is bcuz of Islam vs dogs issues...
Btw, explanation of why dogs preferred in HDB compared to cats is plain dumb and incomprehensible for me. Cats are BY FAR much cleaner than dogs (its in their instinct).
Go figure
That's why it makes much more sense for them NOT to have dogs in the first place, or to hire a kafir to handle the working dogs.zzm9980 wrote:Maybe because you'll clean and cook the meat. You're not going to clean and/or cook your hand or your face when a dog slobbers all over you?
I know it's cool to bash religions, but this is far from the silliest 'rule' that's come out of a religion.
I wasn't religion bashing as such and I agree there are a lot siller things across all religions. Actually I believe under Islam you have to wash yourself 7 times if slobbered on by a dog.zzm9980 wrote:[
Maybe because you'll clean and cook the meat. You're not going to clean and/or cook your hand or your face when a dog slobbers all over you?
I know it's cool to bash religions, but this is far from the silliest 'rule' that's come out of a religion.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest